How to Choose Buttons That Make Handmade Clothing Look Designer-Made

The right buttons can transform handmade clothing from simply finished to beautifully designed. Explore vintage, pearl-look, metal, colorful, fabric-covered, and statement buttons to discover how size, color, material, and placement can give your garments a polished, one-of-a-kind look.

How Button Size, Color, Material, and Placement Can Turn a Handmade Garment Into a Polished, One-of-a-Kind Design

You can spend hours carefully fitting a sewing pattern, choosing beautiful fabric, matching seams, pressing every step, and creating a gorgeous garment—and then finish it with the wrong buttons.

Suddenly, something just doesn't look right.

Buttons may be small, but visually they can have an enormous effect on a garment. They can make handmade clothing look polished and intentional, or they can look like an afterthought.

When you sew your own clothing, don't think of buttons simply as closures.

Think of them as part of the design.

The right buttons can take a simple blouse, dress, cardigan, vest, coat, or jacket and give it that extra detail that makes someone ask:

"Where did you get that?"

And you get to say:

"I made it."

Don't Automatically Buy the Buttons Listed on the Pattern Envelope

A sewing pattern might tell you that you need five ⅝-inch buttons.

That's useful information—but it isn't necessarily a design command.

The pattern company chose a button size and placement that works with the original design. You may decide that another button creates a better look for your version.

Before buying buttons, look at your fabric.

Look at the garment style.

Think about the personality you want the finished garment to have.

Classic?

Romantic?

Vintage?

Tailored?

Playful?

Minimal?

Rustic?

Bold?

Your buttons can reinforce that personality.

Button Size Changes the Entire Look

Button size affects proportion.

Small buttons tend to look delicate and understated. They work beautifully on many blouses, lightweight dresses, and garments where you don't want the closure to dominate the design.

Larger buttons attract attention.

They can look wonderful on jackets, coats, vests, oversized shirts, and garments where the buttons are meant to become part of the visual statement.

But bigger isn't automatically better.

An oversized button on a delicate blouse can overpower the garment, while tiny buttons on a substantial coat may look lost.

Look at the button in relation to the garment—not just by itself.

Put the Buttons on the Fabric Before You Decide

Never judge a button only while it's sitting in a package.

Lay your fabric flat and place several buttons directly on it.

Better yet, if the garment is partly constructed, position the buttons approximately where they will eventually be sewn.

Then step back.

Sometimes a button that looked beautiful in your hand disappears against the fabric.

Another button you weren't sure about suddenly looks perfect.

Try several possibilities before deciding.

This is designing—not indecision!

Matching Buttons Can Create a Polished Look

Buttons don't have to stand out.

Sometimes the most sophisticated choice is a button that blends beautifully with the fabric.

A navy button on a navy jacket can create a clean, tailored appearance.

Cream buttons on an ivory blouse can keep the garment soft and elegant.

Brown or tortoiseshell-style buttons can blend beautifully with earth tones.

When you want the fabric, silhouette, neckline, or sleeves to be the focal point, quieter buttons may be exactly what the garment needs.

Remember what we've learned throughout this creative-design series:

Not every design element needs to compete for attention.

Contrast Buttons Can Become the Design Feature

Now let's do the opposite.

Contrast buttons can completely transform a simple garment.

Imagine:

A navy jacket with pearl-like buttons.

A cream cardigan with dark brown buttons.

A red blouse with black buttons.

A denim dress with colorful buttons.

A black jacket with metallic buttons.

A floral blouse with buttons pulled from one of the smaller colors in the print.

Suddenly, the buttons aren't hiding.

They're participating.

If you use contrast buttons, repeat or connect that contrast somewhere else when appropriate. A contrasting button might coordinate with topstitching, piping, a collar, pocket trim, belt, cuff, or another small design detail.

That helps the contrast look intentional.

Let Printed Fabric Help Choose the Button Color

Printed fabric gives you a ready-made color palette.

Suppose your fabric contains navy, pink, cream, green, and a tiny amount of burgundy.

You could choose buttons in the dominant navy and let them blend.

Or you could pull out that tiny burgundy accent and make it more noticeable.

Both choices can work.

They simply create different designs.

Try placing several button colors on the fabric and see which color your eye responds to.

This is one of the easiest ways to make a handmade garment feel thoughtfully coordinated.

Button Material Matters

Plastic isn't your only option.

Depending on the garment, you might consider:

- wood,

- metal,

- shell or shell-like buttons,

- coconut,

- fabric-covered buttons,

- glass or glass-like buttons,

- horn or horn-look buttons,

- pearl or pearl-look buttons,

- leather-look buttons,

- ceramic or artisan-style buttons.

Each material creates a different feeling.

Wood can feel casual, natural, or rustic.

Metal can make a jacket look tailored or dramatic.

Pearl-like buttons can add softness or elegance.

Fabric-covered buttons can create a beautiful custom finish.

The button material should make sense with both the fabric and the personality of the garment.

Fabric-Covered Buttons Can Look Truly Custom

If you want your garment to look unmistakably made for that particular fabric, consider covered buttons.

You can cover them in the same fabric so they blend almost seamlessly into the garment.

Or use contrast fabric.

Imagine a solid jacket with buttons covered in the floral fabric used for the lining.

Or a floral dress with buttons covered in one coordinating solid color.

That's the kind of detail that makes handmade clothing interesting.

It's subtle.

But someone looking closely will notice.

Vintage Buttons Can Make a New Garment Special

Old buttons can be little pieces of design history.

Vintage button jars, inherited sewing supplies, thrift-store finds, estate-sale sewing boxes, and old garments can contain wonderful buttons that aren't commonly seen on new clothing.

A simple modern jacket can take on an entirely different personality with a beautiful set of vintage buttons.

Before using older buttons, inspect them carefully.

Make sure they aren't cracked, brittle, rusted, damaged, or too fragile for the garment.

And make sure you have enough.

If you need six buttons and own exactly six irreplaceable vintage buttons, consider whether you'd be comfortable if one were eventually lost.

Sometimes having one or two extras is worth considering.

Don't Forget the Button Shank

Some buttons have holes through the face.

Others have a shank underneath.

The choice can affect how the button sits on the garment.

Thicker fabrics often need more room beneath the button so the buttoned fabric can fit comfortably underneath it.

You can also create a thread shank when sewing on certain flat buttons.

A button that is sewn too tightly against thick fabric may pull, pucker, or make the closure difficult to use.

Function matters just as much as appearance.

Button Spacing Can Make a Garment Look More Polished

Even beautiful buttons can look awkward if their placement feels random.

Pay attention to spacing.

Buttons generally look more intentional when the visual rhythm makes sense.

But equal spacing isn't always the only possibility.

Designer garments sometimes use unusual button groupings or spacing as a deliberate feature.

If you're changing the spacing from the original pattern, plan it before making the buttonholes.

Mark all the button positions.

Try on the garment.

Check areas where the garment is likely to pull or gape.

Then make your final decision.

Once you've cut a buttonhole, changing your mind becomes much more difficult!

Pay Special Attention at the Bust

On a button-front blouse or dress, placement around the fullest part of the bust can make the difference between a smooth front and an unwanted gap.

Don't assume the pattern's button placement will automatically be perfect for your body.

Before sewing the buttonholes, try on the garment and check the front carefully.

You may decide that one button needs to sit at a particularly important point to keep the garment closed smoothly.

Then arrange the remaining buttons around it.

Fit comes before perfectly following the printed markings.

Buttons Can Repeat Other Shapes in the Garment

Here's where button selection becomes especially fun.

Look at the shapes already present in your garment.

Does it have:

rounded pockets?

angular lapels?

a square neckline?

soft curved seams?

pointed cuffs?

geometric fabric?

floral fabric?

You can choose buttons that echo those shapes.

Round buttons reinforce curves.

Square or geometric buttons can complement angular design details.

Floral or carved buttons might pick up the character of a print.

You're creating visual relationships within the garment.

That's a designer's way of looking at buttons.

Decorative Buttons Don't Always Have to Function

A button can be purely decorative.

Add buttons to:

pocket flaps,

cuffs,

shoulder tabs,

collars,

back belts,

sleeve details,

or decorative front panels.

A row of small buttons can create visual interest even when none of them opens.

Just make sure decorative buttons look intentional rather than randomly added.

Ask what they contribute to the design.

If the answer is "nothing," leave them off.

Sometimes Fewer Buttons Look Better

A pattern may show eight buttons.

Your design might look better with six.

Or perhaps a jacket originally designed with several small buttons would look striking with three larger ones.

Changing the number of buttons may require adjusting spacing, buttonholes, overlap, and closure security, so it needs to be planned carefully.

But don't assume the original number is your only option.

Remember:

The pattern is the starting point.

Sometimes the Best Button Is the One You Don't Notice

We talk a lot about creative details, but good design also requires knowing when to stop.

If you're sewing with a spectacular print, elaborate embroidery, unusual sleeves, a novelty neckline, or another strong focal point, simple buttons may be best.

They can quietly do their job without asking for attention.

Designer-looking doesn't necessarily mean embellished.

Often it means intentional.

Every element looks as though it belongs there.

Shop Your Button Stash

Before heading to the fabric store, open that button box!

Many sewists have buttons collected from old projects, inherited sewing supplies, discarded garments, thrift finds, or those mysterious little extra-button packets that seem to multiply in drawers.

Sort them by:

color,

size,

material,

style,

and quantity.

Then start experimenting.

Put unexpected buttons against your fabric.

You may discover that the perfect finishing touch has been sitting in your sewing room for years.

Shop Your Closet, Too

Have an old garment that's beyond repair but has beautiful buttons?

Save them.

Buttons are one of the easiest garment components to reuse.

A worn-out cardigan might contain six gorgeous buttons that would look wonderful on a new vest.

An outdated jacket might have metal buttons perfect for another project.

Before discarding a garment, check its hardware and trims.

Your future sewing projects may thank you.

Make a Button Card for Your Project

Here's a simple trick.

When you're deciding among several buttons, pin or temporarily attach your choices to a scrap of the garment fabric.

Write notes beside them if necessary.

Then leave the card somewhere you can look at it for a day or two.

You may find yourself repeatedly drawn to one option.

Sometimes stepping away makes the decision obvious.

One Garment, Completely Different Personalities

Imagine the same simple navy jacket.

Version one has matching navy buttons.

Classic and understated.

Version two has shiny gold-tone buttons.

Polished and bold.

Version three has wood buttons.

Casual and natural.

Version four has pearl-like buttons.

Soft and unexpected.

Version five has fabric-covered floral buttons.

Creative and unmistakably handmade in the best possible way.

The jacket pattern didn't change.

The fabric didn't change.

Only the buttons changed.

Yet each jacket tells a different story.

Look at Buttons With a Designer's Eye

The next time you're finishing a handmade garment, don't reach automatically for the first package of buttons that matches.

Experiment.

Try different sizes.

Compare materials.

Test matching and contrasting colors.

Study the proportions.

Consider the fabric.

Think about the other design details.

Check the spacing.

And ask yourself:

What do I want these buttons to do for this garment?

Do you want them to disappear?

Coordinate?

Contrast?

Add elegance?

Create a vintage feeling?

Become the focal point?

Once you know the answer, choosing the right buttons becomes much easier.

Because buttons aren't merely the things that hold your garment closed.

They're one more opportunity to make the design your own.

Go Button Shopping in Your Own Sewing Room

Before buying new buttons, take another look through the buttons you already own. Open those jars, tins, boxes, and drawers and pull out the vintage buttons you've been saving for something special. That “something special” might be your next handmade garment!

Lay different buttons directly on your fabric and experiment with size, color, material, and contrast. Try the unexpected ones, too. A button you might never have considered could be exactly what turns a simple blouse, dress, vest, or jacket into a one-of-a-kind design.

Then browse the sewing patterns at The Needle Market Shop for even more inspiration. Look beyond the garment pictured on the envelope and imagine how it might change with pearl-look buttons, vintage metal buttons, colorful statement buttons, wood buttons, or beautiful fabric-covered buttons.

Shop your stash. Try something unexpected. Let the buttons become part of the design.

Is this article helpful and informative to you? If so, subscribe to The Designer's Needle in the sidebar for articles like this delivered to your inbox.